No ke aha i holoi ai ʻo Forbes i kekahi ʻatikala Kavin Senapathy

Print enamel Share Tweet

Na wai e uku iā Kavin Senapathy e hoʻolaha i nā GMO? 

Ua puka ʻo Kavin Senapathy ma ke ʻano he mea kākau ma 2015 me nā ʻatikala e paipai ana i nā GMO, ka pale ʻana i nā pesticides a me ka hōʻeha ʻana i nā loiloi o ka ʻoihana mahiʻai, ʻo ka hapa nui o lākou i paʻi ʻia ma Forbes. ʻAʻole ʻo ia e hōʻike i kāna kumuwaiwai kālā.

I ka 2017, Forbes ua kāpae i nā ʻatikala ʻehiku a Senapathy i kākau pū ʻia me ʻO Henry I. Miller, kahi hoa ʻoihana ʻo Hoover Institution, e ukali nei nā hōʻike i ka New York Times ua kākau ʻo Ghostanto i kahi ʻatikala i paʻi ʻia ma lalo o ka inoa o Miller ma Forbes. Ua wehe ʻo Forbes i kahi ʻatikala a Senapathy i kākau ai e pili ana i ka transparency, i nele i ka transparency. Aia nō ma ka pūnaewele Forbes kahi Haawina Ua kākau pū ʻo ia me Cameron English, ka mea hana no ka ʻAha ʻAmelika ma ʻEpekema a me ke olakino, a hui mua i uku ʻia e Monsanto.

ʻO Senapathy's Pākuʻi ʻia ma ka ʻikepili papa inoa iā ia ma ke ʻano he mea kākau hāʻawi i Hoʻopuka Haʻawina Genetic, kahi mahiʻai ʻē aʻe pūʻulu alo o ka ʻoihana hana like me Monsanto.

Ua hoʻokumu pū ʻo Senapathy iā March Against Modification Myths (ʻO MAMyths), kahi hui e hoʻonohonoho i nā kūʻē i ka poʻe loiloi biotechnology (a me kahi pili o ka hui hoʻolaha GMO Biofortified). Ua kākau inoa ʻo ia i 2015 buke hoʻolaha ia i nā GMO, nā koi aspartame a palekana ʻo MSG, a me ka manaʻo e wehewehe i nā "ʻoiaʻiʻo ma hope o kēlā mau makaʻi pesticide weliweli."

Ma ka liʻiliʻi loa ʻehiku ʻatikala i lawe ʻia e Forbes 

Hana pū me Henry I. Miller 

Ua hoʻomaka ʻo Senapathy e kaʻana like i kahi byline me Henry Miller ma 2015 ma kahi o nā ʻatikala ma Forbes e pale ana i nā GMO. ʻO nā ʻatikala paipai ʻia ma aneʻi na ka Hoover Institution, kahi manaʻo manaʻo politika i loaʻa kālā mai nā ʻaoʻao ʻēheu ʻākau a me nā ʻoihana.

Ua holoi ʻo Forbes i ka ʻatikala ʻo Miller / Senapathy i ke ala ʻana i ʻAukake 2017 Hōʻike ʻo New York Times:

"Hōʻike nā palapala i makemake ʻo Henry I. Miller… iā Monsanto e kākau i kahi ʻatikala nona i hōʻike nui ʻia i hōʻike ʻia ma lalo o kona inoa ma ka pūnaewele ʻo Forbes ma 2015 ... Ua wehe ʻo Forbes i ka moʻolelo mai kāna pūnaewele i ka Pōʻakolu a ua ʻōlelo ʻia ua pau ka pilina me Mr. . Miller i waena o nā hōʻike. "

ʻO kahi mea ma loko Retraction Watch ʻōlelo ʻo Mia Carbonell, VP kiʻekiʻe o nā kamaʻilio honua ma Forbes:

"Kākau inoa nā mea kōkua āpau iā Forbes.com i kahi ʻaelike e koi ana iā lākou e hōʻike i nā hakakā kūʻē o ka hoihoi a e hoʻopuka wale i nā ʻike i kā lākou kākau ponoʻī. I ko mākou ʻike ʻana ua uhaʻi ʻo Mr. Miller i kēia mau ʻōlelo, ua wehe mākou i kāna mau pou āpau mai Forbes.com a ua pau ko mākou pilina me ia. "

ka nā leka uila ma waena o Miller a me kahi luna ʻo Monsanto e hōʻike i ka hana ʻana o nā ʻoihana me nā mea kākau e like me Miller e hoʻolaha i nā helu kamaʻilio ʻoihana ʻoiai e hūnā i kā lākou hana pū ʻana. I kēia hihia, ua noi aku kahi luna Monsanto iā Miller e kākau i kahi kolamu e pale aku ana i ka glyphosate a hāʻawi iā ia i kahi "kikoʻī paʻakikī" e like me "kahi hoʻomaka maikaʻi no kāu kilokilo." Ua ʻike ʻia ke kikoʻī i kekahi mau lā ma hope ma Forbes, hoʻololi nui ʻia, ma lalo o ka inoa o Miller.

Blunder Transparency

ʻO Forbes kekahi weheʻia ma ka liʻiliʻi hoʻokahi ʻatikala me ka laina byline o Senapathy. ʻO ka ʻāpana ʻo ʻAukake 17, "Hāʻawi kēia Haʻawina Crowdfunded i kahi Haʻawina no ka Transparency" (i kēia manawa Medium), hoʻohewa iā Monsanto no nā loiloi palekana ghostwriting no glyphosate, e wehewehe nei i ka hanana ma ke ʻano he "transparency blunder" a me "PR gaffe." ʻOiai ua paʻi ʻia he mau pule ma hope o ka hōʻike ʻana o ka nūhou ua kākau ʻo Monsanto i kahi ʻatikala na kāna mea kōkua ʻo Henry Miller, ua kāpae ʻia ka ʻatikala a Senapathy e pili ana i ka transparency.

Ua hāpai ʻia nā “mea kūʻē kānāwai” e pili ana i ke “kūʻokoʻa”

I loko o kahi Syndicate Project Project 2015 Haawina i kapa ʻia ʻo "GMOs a me Junk Science," ua hoʻopiʻi ʻo Senapathy a me Miller i nā ʻoihana meaola a me nā ʻoihana maoli o ka hōʻino ʻana i ka mana ʻepekema a hana i nā hoʻolaha. Pākuʻi ʻia ka Project Syndicate palapala a kēia luna hoʻoponopono i ka ʻāpana ma ʻAukake 4, 2017:



"Ua hāpai ʻia nā kūʻē kūʻē e pili ana i ke kūʻokoʻa a me ke kūpaʻa o nā ʻōlelo a Henry Miller i kākau ai no Project Syndicate a me nā wahi ʻē aʻe, ʻo ia hoʻi ʻo Monsanto, ʻaʻole ʻo Miller, i hoʻolālā i kekahi o lākou. E hoʻomaopopo paha ka poʻe heluhelu i kēia hakakā kūʻē o ka hoihoi, inā i ʻike ʻia ia i ka manawa i ʻae ʻia ai nā ʻōlelo a Miller, he kumu ia no ka hōʻole ʻana iā lākou. ”

Nā Tactics Underhanded o MAMyths 

ʻO Senapathy ka mea hui pū o March Against Myths of Modification, a hui hoʻonohonoho i nā kūʻē e kū i ka poʻe loiloi o ka ʻoihana mahiʻai, e like me ʻO Kauka Vandana Shiva, a hoʻohana i kekahi manawa i nā kaʻao underhanded. I ka 2016, ua hoʻāla ʻo MAMyths i kahi hoʻāʻo i hoʻohoka ʻole i kahi Center no ka hanana palekana meaʻai ma Hawaii e hōʻike ana iā Vani Hari, The Babe Mea ʻai.

E like me Hari i wehewehe ai i loko o kahi Haawina e pili ana i ka Episode:

"24 mau hola ma mua o koʻu hoʻonohonoho ʻia ʻana e hele i ke kahua, ua hōʻike ʻia au e Hawaii CFS ua hoʻokumu ka pro-GMO a me ka hui hana activist satire (MAMyths) i kahi hana e hoʻomeamea i ka hanana. ʻAʻohe manuahi nā tikika i ka hanana, akā ua nui ka nui o ka loaʻa i hiki i nā wahi ke hoʻokipa i kekahi mau kānaka…

Ua noi ʻo MAMyths i kā lākou poʻe ukali e mālama i nā palaka o nā likiki e hoʻohana nei i nā inoa hoʻopunipuni a me nā leka uila ʻole e ʻike ʻia e "kūʻai lilo ʻia" ana a e kamaʻilio pū ana mākou i kahi wahi hakahaka. Ua mālama lākou ma kahi o 1,500 mau tikika e hoʻohana nei i nā inoa e like me "Fraud Babe," "Organic is Dumb," "Susi Creamcheese," a me "Harriett Tubman" mai nā IP i ʻike ʻia ma waho o Hawaii a me nā ʻāina ʻē ma United Kingdom, Australia, Kina, Thailand, Kelemania. , Kuekene, a me Nekelana.

ʻAʻole lākou i kūleʻa no ka mea ua ʻike ʻo Hawaii CFS kahi i hele mai ai kēia mau noi bogus a ua hiki ke hoʻopau maʻalahi i kā lākou mālama ʻana. ”

Koi ʻo MAMyths i kā lākou paena ʻaʻole lākou i "uku ʻia e Monsanto a i ʻole nā ​​ʻoihana ʻē aʻe. He manawaleʻa mākou āpau me ka makemake nui i ka hoʻopono a hana i kēia i kā mākou makemake kūʻokoʻa. " Wahi a Senapathy's Bio ma ka pūnaewele, "Manaʻo ʻo ia he kī nui ka noʻonoʻo loi i ka hānai ʻana i nā keiki poepoe maikaʻi, a ʻo ka ʻapo ʻana i ka biotechnology ka mea e pono ai kēia pahuhopu."

Ke wehewehe nei ka puke i ka neʻe ʻana o ka meaʻai ma ke ʻano he “Terrorist Faction”

ʻO Senapathy ka mea kākau pū o a buke, "The Babe makaʻu: Wāwahi ʻo Vani Hari's Glass House," i paʻi ʻia ma ʻOkakopa 2015 e Paipalapala ʻo Senapath. Paipai ka puke i nā meaʻai ʻenekini genetically, nā kuleana aspartame a palekana ʻo MSG, a me ka manaʻo e wehewehe i nā "ʻoiaʻiʻo ma hope o kēlā mau makaʻi pesticide weliweli."

ʻO nā hoa kākau ʻo Mark Alsip, kahi mea kākau blog na Hoʻopau ʻia ka ʻepekema maikaʻi ʻole, a ʻO Marc Draco, ka mea i wehewehe ʻia ma ke ʻano he lālā kūpuna o ka Papa ʻia e Food Babe ʻAoʻao Facebook. Ua kākau ʻia ka mua e Ke Kulanui o Florida ʻO Polofesa Kevin Folta.

ʻO ka puke i mua hōʻike ʻo ka neʻe ʻana o ka meaʻai ma ke ʻano he "elite o kēia au elite a me ka hoʻoweliweli kālā ua hoʻohiki ka ʻaoʻao hoʻoweliweli e hoʻohana i ka makaʻu e koi i ka hoʻololi politika e pili ana i ka meaʻai," a me kahi "pūʻulu hoʻoweliweli agile a sneaky. E like me nā pūʻulu hoʻoweliweli āpau e hoʻokō lākou i kā lākou mau pahuhopu ma o ka hoʻokō ʻana i ka makaʻu a me ke kaohi. "

Nā ʻĀina ʻoihana Kemika

Ua hōʻuluʻulu ʻo USRTK i kahi moʻo e pili ana i nā mea kākau a me nā hui PR e hilinaʻi ana ka ʻoihana mahiʻai e hana i ka kānalua e pili ana i ka ʻepekema e hāpai i ka hopohopo e pili ana i nā huahana pilikia a hoʻopaʻapaʻa i nā pale olakino kaiapuni.
No ke aha ʻoe i hilinaʻi ʻole ai iā Henry I. Miller
- Hoʻomaʻa ʻo Julie Kelly i ka Propaganda no ka ʻOihana Kemika
ʻO ka American Council on Science and Health ka ʻoihana mua ʻoihana
ʻO Jon Entine o ka Papahana Heluhelu Genetic: ʻO kā Messenger Messenger ʻoihana Kemika
ʻO Trevor Butterworth / ʻIke e pili ana i ka ʻepekema Spins Science no ka ʻOihana
- Pākuʻi paha ʻo Science Media Center i nā ʻike ʻoihana?

E hāhai i ka hoʻokolokolo a USRTK o Big Food a me kāna mau hui mua: https://usrtk.org/our-investigations/