Kungani iForbes Isuse Ezinye Izindatshana ZaseKavin Senapathy

Phrinta imeyili Ungahlukıselana Ephathwayo

Ngubani okhokhela uKavin Senapathy ukukhuthaza ama-GMO? 

UKavin Senapathy uvele njengombhali ngo-2015 enezindatshana ezikhuthaza ama-GMO, evikela ama-pesticides kanye nabahlaseli abagxekayo bemboni yezolimo, iningi labo elishicilelwe eForbes. Akayidaluli imithombo yakhe yezimali.

Ku-2017, iForbes isuse izindatshana eziyisikhombisa uSenapathy ahlanganiswe nazo UHenry I. Miller, owake waba ngumuntu waseHoover Institution, olandelayo izambulo kuNew York Times ukuthi uMonsanto ubhale isipoki ngendatshana eshicilelwe ngaphansi kwegama likaMiller eForbes. UForbes uphinde wasusa udaba uSenapathy alubhalile mayelana nokwenza izinto obala, okwakushoda obala. Namanje phezulu kusayithi leForbes yi- esihlokweni ubhalisane noCameron English, osebenzela i-American Council on Science and Health, a iqembu langaphambili elikhokhelwa iMonsanto.

KaSenapathy Iphrofayili exhunyiwe umbeka ohlwini njengombhali onikela ku Iphrojekthi ye-genetic Literacy Project, enye yezolimo umkhakha weqembu eliphambili lokho kusebenza eduze neMonsanto.

ISenapathy yasungula ngokubambisana iMarch Against Modification Myths (MAMyths), iqembu elihlela imibhikisho elwa nabagxeki be-biotechnology (kanye nenxusa leqembu le-GMO promotion Kwenziwe kabusha). Ubuye wabhala u-2015 ibhuku lokho kukhuthaza ama-GMO, izimangalo i-aspartame futhi i-MSG iphephile, futhi ihlose ukuchaza "amaqiniso abangela ukwesabeka kwezibulala-zinambuzane ezinobuthi."

Okungenani Imibhalo Eyisikhombisa Isuswe yiForbes 

Ukusebenzisana noHenry I. Miller 

USenapathy waqala ukwabelana ngomugqa noHenry Miller ngo-2015 ochungechungeni lwezindatshana zeForbes ezivikela ama-GMO. Izindatshana yilezi kukhushulwe lapha yi-Hoover Institution, ithangi lokucabanga lenqubomgomo lelo ithola uxhaso kusuka kuzisekelo zamaphiko angakwesokudla kanye nezinkampani.

IForbes isuse izindatshana zeMiller / Senapathy ngemuva kuka-Agasti 2017 Umbiko weNew York Times:

"Imibhalo ikhombisa ukuthi uHenry I. Miller… ucele uMonsanto ukuba amenzele incwadi azoyibonisa ikakhulukazi ebibhalwe ngegama lakhe kuwebhusayithi yeForbes ngonyaka ka-2015… IForbes iyisusile le ndaba kwi-website yayo ngoLwesithathu yathi yaqeda ubuhlobo bayo noMnu. Miller phakathi kwezambulo. ”

Isihloko ku I-Watch Retraction ucaphuna uMia Carbonell, i-VP ephezulu yezokuxhumana emhlabeni wonke eForbes:

“Bonke ababambe iqhaza kuForbes.com basayina inkontileka edinga ukuthi badalule noma yikuphi ukungqubuzana kwezintshisekelo okungaba khona futhi bashicilele kuphela okuqukethwe okungumbhalo wabo wokuqala. Kuthe lapho sifika ukuthi uMnu. Miller wephule le migomo, sakususa konke abengakuthumele kuForbes.com futhi saqeda ubudlelwano bethu naye. ”

The ama-imeyili phakathi kukaMiller nomphathi weMonsanto khombisa ukuthi izinkampani zisebenza kanjani nababhali abanjengoMiller ukukhuthaza amaphuzu okukhuluma embonini ngenkathi begcina ukusebenzisana kwabo kuyimfihlo. Kulokhu, umphathi we-Monsanto wacela uMiller ukuthi abhale ikholomu evikela i-glyphosate futhi wamnikeza "okusalukhuni impela" njengokuthi "kuyisiqalo esihle somlingo wakho." Okusalungiswa kwavela ezinsukwini ezimbalwa kamuva ku Forbes, ikakhulukazi engashintshiwe, ngaphansi kwegama likaMiller.

Ukungaboni Okusobala

Forbes futhi isusiwe okungenani i-athikili eyodwa enomugqa wedwa kaSenapathy. Isiqephu sika-Agasti 17, "Lesi Sivivinyo Sokuxhaswa Kwabantu Abaningi Sinikeza Isifundo Sokubonisa Ngale" (manje esivele ku Medium), wagxeka iMonsanto ngokubuyekezwa kokuphepha kwe-ghostphosate, echaza lesi sigameko njenge- "transparency blunder" kanye ne- "PR gaffe." Yize kushicilelwe emavikini ngemuva kwemibiko yezindaba yokuthi uMonsanto ubhale i-athikili kumuntu asebenzisana naye uHenry Miller, udaba lukaSenapathy mayelana nokwenza izinto obala alukwazanga ukusho lelo qiniso.

"Ukuphikisana okusemthethweni" kuphakanyisiwe mayelana "nokuzimela"

Ku-Sept. 2015 Project Syndicate esihlokweni enesihloko esithi “GMOs and Junk Science,” uSenapathy noMiller basola izimboni zokudla zemvelo nokusebenzisa kabi igunya lesayensi nokukhipha inkulumo-ze. I-Project Syndicate ingeziwe inothi yalo mhleli esiqeshini ngo-Agasti 4, 2017:



“Kuphakanyiswe izikhalazo ezisemthethweni mayelana nokuzimela nobuqotho bezincazelo uHenry Miller azibhalele iProject Syndicate nezinye izitolo, ikakhulukazi ukuthi uMonsanto, esikhundleni sikaMiller, wabhala ezinye zazo. Abafundi kufanele bazi ngalolu dlame olungaba khona lokuthakazelisa, obekuthi, ukube kwaziwa ngaleso sikhathi lapho kwamukelwa khona ukuphawula kukaMiller, ngabe kwaba yizizathu zokuzinqaba. ”

Amaqhinga angaphansi kwamaMAMyths 

USenapathy ungumsunguli we-March Against Myths of Modification, a iqembu ehlela imibhikisho ukubhekana nabagxeki bemboni yezolimo, njenge UDkt Vandana Shiva, futhi kwesinye isikhathi isebenzisa amaqhinga afihliwe. Ku-2016, ama-MAMyths ahlela umzamo ohlulekile wokunciphisa umcimbi weSikhungo Sokuphepha Kokudla eHawaii obonisa uVani Hari, iThe Food Babe.

Njengoba uHari echaze ku esihlokweni mayelana nesiqephu:

“Emahoreni angama-24 ngaphambi kokuba ngihlelelwe ukungena esteji, ngaziswe yiHawaii CFS ukuthi iqembu elalisekela i-GMO kanye neqembu lezishoshovu zokulingisa (MAMyths) laqala umkhankaso wokucekela phansi lo mcimbi. Amathikithi alo mcimbi abemahhala, kodwa bekunenani elilinganiselwe elitholakalayo njengoba indawo ibizokwazi ukuhlalisa abantu abathile kuphela…

I-MAMyths icele abalandeli bayo ukuthi bagcine amathikithi wamathikithi besebenzisa amagama angombombayi nama-imeyili mbumbulu ukuze kubonakale sengathi "kuthengisiwe" nokuthi sizobe sikhuluma endaweni engenalutho. Babekise amathikithi angaphezu kuka-1,500 XNUMX besebenzisa amagama anjenge- “Fraud Babe,” “Organic is Dumb,” “Susi Creamcheese,” ne- “Harriett Tubman” asuka kumakheli we-IP atholakala ngaphandle kweHawaii naphesheya kwezilwandle e-United Kingdom, Australia, China, Thailand, Germany , Sweden, kanye neNetherlands.

Aziphumelelanga ngoba iCFS yaseHawaii ithole ukuthi lezi zicelo mbumbulu zivela kuphi futhi yakwazi ukukhansela kalula ukubhuka kwazo. ”

Izimangalo ze-MAMyths ku- iwebhusayithi azikhokhelwa yiMonsanto noma enye imboni. Sonke singamavolontiya anothando lobulungiswa futhi lokhu sikwenza ngokuthanda kwethu. ” Ngokusho kukaSenapathy bio esizeni, "Ukholelwa ukuthi ukucabanga okunzulu kubalulekile ekukhuliseni izingane eziqoqekile, nokuthi ukwamukela i-biotechnology kubalulekile kule nhloso."

Incwadi Ichaza Ukunyakaza Kokudla "Njengengxenye Yamaphekula"

USenapathy ungumbhali-mbhali we-a ibhuku, “The Fear Babe: Shattering Vani Hari's Glass House,” eyashicilelwa ngo-Okthoba 2015 ngu ISenapath Press. Incwadi ikhuthaza ukudla okwenziwe ngezakhi zofuzo, izimangalo i-aspartame futhi i-MSG iphephile, futhi ihlose ukuchaza "amaqiniso abangela ukwesabeka kwezibulala-zinambuzane ezinobuthi."

Ababhali abambisene nabo nguMark Alsip, i-blogger ye- Isayensi Engalungile Ikhishwe, noMarc Draco, ochazwa njengelungu lomakadebona le- Kuvinjelwe Ukudla Babe Ikhasi le-Facebook. Ukuya phambili kubhalwe yiYunivesithi yaseFlorida USolwazi Kevin Folta.

Incwadi iye phambili ichaza ukunyakaza kokudla “njengeqembu lamaphekula lwanamuhla elisezingeni eliphakeme futhi elixhaswe kahle ngemali elifungile ukuthi lizosebenzisa ukwesaba ukuphoqelela ushintsho lwezepolitiki ezungeze ukudla,” kanye neqembu “lamaphekula agile futhi anyonyobayo. Njengawo wonke amaqembu amaphekula afeza izinhloso zawo ngokusebenzisa ukwesaba nokuphoqa. ”

Amakhemikhali Emboni Yezamakhemikhali

I-USRTK ihlanganise uchungechunge lwamaphepha amaqiniso ngabalobi namaqembu e-PR imboni yezolimo ithembele ekwenziweni kokungabaza ngesayensi ephakamisa ukukhathazeka ngemikhiqizo eyingozi futhi ephikisana nokuvikelwa kwempilo yezemvelo.
Kungani Ungethembi UHenry I. Miller
- UJulie Kelly Upheka Inkulumo-ze Yezimboni Zamakhemikhali
I-American Council on Science and Health yiCorporate Front Group
UJon Entine weProjekthi Yezifundo Zokufunda Nokubhala: I-Master Industry's Master Messenger
UTrevor Butterworth / Sense Mayelana neSayensi Isebenzisa Isayensi Yezimboni
- Ngabe Isayensi Yezindaba Yesikhungo Ishintsha Ukubukwa Kwebhizinisi Lwesayensi?

Landela uphenyo lwe-USRTK Lokudla Okukhulu namaqembu alo angaphambili: https://usrtk.org/our-investigations/