Ukubika Kusuka Enkantolo

Phrinta imeyili Ungahlukıselana Ephathwayo

Imibhalo evela kuSuku 1 ecaleni likaHardeman ithunyelwe lapha.

Bheka Umbhalo wezinqubo.

Bona Ideski Lesilayidi Lokuvula Lommangali futhi Ideski Lesilayidi Lokuvula leMonsanto

I-3: 30 pm Ijaji lichithiwe yijaji kodwa abameli ecaleni lokuhlolwa umdlavuza iRoundup basadingida ukuthi ubufakazi bungasetshenziswa kanjani noma bungasetshenziswa kanjani. Usathukuthele kakhulu ngommeli wommangali u-Aimee Wagstaff onesibindi sokukhuluma ngo-1983 @EPA dox ekhombisa ukukhathazeka ngomdlavuza nge-glyphosate.

Ijaji liphinda liqola u-Aimee Wagstaff futhi futhi uthi ufuna ukumjezisa ngo- $ 1,000 XNUMX futhi mhlawumbe nethimba labammeli lonke. Ukubiza izenzo zakhe "njengesimungulu ngokumangazayo."

2: 30pm thumela izibuyekezo zasemini:

  • Ngenkathi kuqalwa ukuhlolwa kwesifo somdlavuza seMonsanto Roundup, ufakazi kommangali uBeate Ritz ukhuluma namajaji ngama-ratios engcuphe, izikhawu zokuzethemba nokubaluleka kwezibalo zesayensi yomdlavuza. Ithinta inani lokuhlaziywa kwe-meta. @Bayer
  • UDkt Ritz ufakaza ngezifundo ezahlukahlukene ezibonisa ukwanda kwengcuphe yomdlavuza kusuka ekuvezweni kwe-glyphosate.
  • Ummangali u-Edwin Hardeman nomkakhe babukela buthule, kepha ngesikhathi sekhefu bazwakalise ukukhungatheka ngokuthi uJaji Chhabria unobufakazi obulinganiselwe ijaji elilalelayo.
  • Indlela eqinisekile yomlilo yokudonsela ukuphikisana nabameli baka @Bayer Monsanto ocwaningweni lomdlavuza weRoundup: yisho @IARCWHO ukuhlukaniswa kwesayensi kwe-glyphosate njenge-carcinogen engaba khona.
  • Usuku lokuqala lwe- @ Bayer Monsanto Roundup umdlavuza wesivivinyo uphetha ngemuva kobufakazi obude obuvela kusosayensi uBeate Ritz ohamba ngamajaji ngocwaningo olukhombisa ubungozi be-NHL ekuvezweni kwe-glyphosate herbicides. Ijaji libonga amajaji ngokulalelisisa; ubatshela ukuthi baziqhelelanise nabezindaba.

  • Usuku olulodwa kuphela esivivinyweni somdlavuza we-Roundup esilahlekelwa yi-juror. Omunye walaba bantu ababili abasemajele uthi basebenza kanzima; akakwazi ukulahlekelwa ngumholo wakhe. Lokho kushiya abesifazane abangu-7 nendoda e-1 ukuthi ithathe isinqumo ngecala. Isinqumo kumele sivumelane ngazwi linye ukuthi ummangali uwine.

11: 38 amUbufakazi bomsindo wejaji ekuvuleni kwecala lomdlavuza i-Roundup: i-oda langaphambi kokuqulwa kwecala lommeli wommangali ukukhombisa isizathu sokuthi kungani kungafanele anikezwe unswinyo ngo-8 ebusuku namhlanje.

11: 10 am IMonsanto / Bayer isonga ukuvulwa kwayo futhi manje ilungiselela ufakazi wokuqala, usosayensi ongummangali uBeate Ritz. Ukubuyekezwa okuningi kusuka kusitatimende sokuvula:

  • Ummeli kommangali ubiza ibha eseceleni njengoba lezo zitatimende bezivinjelwe yimiyalo yangaphambi kokuqulwa kwecala kepha ijaji liyamhlula.
  • Manje ummeli weMonsanto ukhombisa ishadi elithi ngenkathi ukusetshenziswa kwe-glyphosate kukhuphukile ngaphezu kwamashumi eminyaka, amanani eNHL awazange. Ube esethi yize i- @ IARCWHO ihlukaniswa njenge-glyphosate njenge-carcinogen engaba khona @EPA & abalawuli bangaphandle abavumelani.
  • Ummeli wezokuvikela uMonsanto @Bayer kuhlu; ukutshela ama-jurors konke nge-Agricultural Health Study, engakhombisanga buhlobo phakathi kwe-glyphosate ne-non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Ummeli uveza ukuthi uMonsanto wayengahlangene ngalutho nalolu cwaningo.

10: 45 amManje ngu @Bayer Ithuba likaMonsanto lokuthola izitatimende zokuvula - ummeli uBrian Stekloff utshela ijaji "I-Roundup ayibanga yisi sifo sikaMnu. Hardeman esingeyona iHodgkin lymphoma."

  • Ijaji liyala nje enye iMonsanto @Bayer kususwe isilayidi, kuphazamisa isitatimende sokuvula kommeli wabameli. Ukudlala ibhola elinzima ngazo zombili izinhlangothi.
  • Ummeli kommangali uphikisana nelinye lama-slides abameli beMonsanto; ijaji liyavuma bese kususwa isilayidi. Icala lommeli wezokuvikela ukuthi umlando kaHardeman weHepatitis C kungenzeka usolwe ngeNHL yakhe.
  • Utshela ama-jurors i-NHL uhlobo olujwayelekile lomdlavuza futhi iningi lezisulu ze-NHL akubona abasebenzisi beRoundup; akukho ukuhlolwa udokotela angakusebenzisa ukutshela isiguli ukuthi isifo sakhe sibangelwe noma asibangekanga yiRoundup.

10: 15 izibuyekezo kumazwi okuvula kommeli wommangali u-Aimee Wagstaff:

  • Ijaji manje lisabisa ngokujezisa ummeli wommangali futhi licabangisise ngokuthi kufanele yini anqabe ukuvumela ijaji ukuthi libone amaslayidi kommangali. Ummeli ka- @Bayer Monsanto uthi yebo. U-Aimee ucela ukubhekana nokukhathazeka kwakhe; ijaji liyamsika.
  • Ijaji manje liyalahla amajaji ngekhefu bese kuthi i-RIPS ibe ngummeli wommangali - ithi "weqe umugqa" futhi "akafanele neze" ezitatimendeni zakhe zokuqala. Uthi lesi "yisixwayiso sakhe sokugcina". Ungalokothi ube mzuzu obuthuntu ku @Bayer Isilingo somdlavuza weMonsanto Roundup.
  • Ijaji liphinde limtshele ukuthi "aqhubeke" lapho ezama ukuchaza ukuthi @EPA ihlola kuphela i-glyphosate hhayi umkhiqizo ophelele.
  • Uvunyelwe ukushiwo kafushane ngo @IARCWHO ukuhlukaniswa kwe-glyphosate njenge-carcinogen yabantu kodwa ijaji liyamsika ngaphambi kokuthi asho okuningi.
  • Esitatimendeni sokuvula se- @Bayer Ummeli wommangali wesimangalo seMonsanto Roundup ukhomba ekuhlaziyweni okusha kwe-meta okukhombisa izibopho ezinamandla zomdlavuza (bheka Indaba kaGuardian).
  • Esitatimendeni sokuvula sommeli wommangali kommangalelwa we-Roundup ufundwa kusukela ngo-1980s-era @EPA imemo "i-glyphosate iyasola" futhi idlula indaba yokuthi iMonsanto yakwenza kanjani ukuguqulwa kokukhathazeka kwe-EPA. Amajaji abukeka edidekile ngayo yonke le nto yesayensi.

9: 35 am Manje ummeli wommangali exoxa ngendaba yocwaningo lwegundane lwango-1983 olwenza ososayensi be-@EPAss ukuthi bathole umdlavuza we-glyphosate obangela… ngaphambi kokuba uMonsanto abaqinisekise. hhawu. Ijaji liyamsika futhi. Ibha eseceleni. @BayerMonsanto kufanele ikuthande lokhu. Ukuthola okwengeziwe ngocwaningo lwamagundane lwango-1983, bheka indatshana ka-2017,Ezamagundane, iMonsanto kanye neSimila Esiyimfihlakalo."

9: 30 am Indikimba enkulu namhlanje ekuseni ijaji alinikezi mmeli wommangali inkululeko, nge @careygillam:

8: 49 am IJaji uChhabria ukhombisa ukusheshe alinqande leli cala lomdlavuza iRoundup. Umise ummeli kommangali u-Aimee Wagstaff kungakapheli nemizuzu emingaki evulelwe ibha eseceleni. UWagstaff uvule ngokwethula unkosikazi kommangali, waqala ukukhuluma ngendaba yempilo yabo noHardeman bathola isigaxa entanyeni yakhe. Ijaji liphazamisile latshela uWagstaff ukuthi abambelele kumazwana abhekele udaba kuphela.

8: 10 am "Inkantolo manje iyaqhubeka". Igumbi lenkantolo ligcwele phama ngezitatimende zokuvula ecaleni lokuhlolwa komdlavuza iRoundup. Zisuka nje kululwane, uMonsanto Bayer, nabameli bommangali sebevele sebephikisana nobufakazi obuzolethwa.

8: 00 am Futhi sesihambile. Ezinyangeni eziyisithupha ngemuva kwejaji laseCalifornia linqume ababulali bokhula bakaMonsanto kubangele umdlavuza womgcini wezindawo, elinye ijaji laseCalifornia lilungiselela ukuzwa izimpikiswano ezifanayo ezibhekene neMonsanto.

Ngalesi sikhathi icala kuzwakala enkantolo yombuso, hhayi enkantolo yombuso. Okubalulekile, ijaji livumile ngesicelo esivela kuMonsanto sokuzama leli cala ngezigaba ezimbili ezinobufakazi bokuziphatha okunganaki nokukhohlisa okungenziwa nguMonsanto esigodliwe esigabeni sokuqala ukuvumela ijaji ukuthi ligxile kuphela ebufakazini obuphathelene nombuzo wokuthi noma cha imikhiqizo yenkampani bekufanele isolwe ngomdlavuza wommangali.

Ummangali u-Edwin Hardeman uphethwe yi-B-cell non-Hodgkin lymphoma, eyatholakala ngoFebhuwari 2015, kusasele inyanga eyodwa ngaphambi kokuba i-International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) ihlukanise i-glyphosate, isithako esibalulekile eMonsanto's Roundup nakwezinye izinhlobo zemithi yokubulala ukhula, njenge “ kungenzeka i-carcinogen yomuntu.

UHardeman wasebenzisa imikhiqizo yeRoundup njalo ukwelapha ukhula nokukhula ngokweqile epheshaneni lamahektare angama-56 ayenalo eSonoma County. Imibhalo efakwe enkantolo yombuso ephathelene nokuqulwa kwecala likaHardeman ingaba utholwe lapha.

Abesifazane abayisikhombisa nabesilisa ababili bakhethwa njengamajaji ukulalela leli cala likaHardeman. Ijaji lithe leli cala kumele liqhubeke kuze kuphele uMashi. Izolo iJaji uChhabria unqabele uMonsanto isiphakamiso sokuthi kufinyelelwe enkantolo.