Ka hopena o ka ʻoihana ma ke Kulanui o Saskatchewan: ʻo Professor Peter Phillips a me kāna "huna e ʻike i ka simposium"

Print enamel Share Tweet

He ʻumi tausani ʻaoʻao o nā palapala kūloko i loaʻa iā Pono ʻo US e ʻike ma o nā noi palapala lehulehu e hōʻike i ka pili - a pinepine pinepine - nā pilina ma waena o Monsanto, kāna mau pūʻulu PR, a me kahi hui o nā polofesa e hoʻolaha nei i nā GMO a me nā pesticides. I hoʻokahi laʻana, ua huli ka hoʻokolokolo i nā kikoʻī e pili ana i kā Monsanto hana me ʻO Peter WB Phillips, Kumu Kula Hanohano ma ka ʻO Johnson Shoyama puka kula o ke kulekele aupuni, Kulanui o Saskatchewan.

Aia nā hōʻike i nā hōʻike e pili ana i nā limahana o Monsanto hāʻawi ʻia a hoʻoponopono ʻia kahi pepa a Phillips i kākau ai, a komo i loko o kahi pani-i-ka-lehulehu "simposium" Ua hoʻonohonoho ʻo Phillips ma ka U o S e kūkākūkā ai i nā pilikia transparency e pili ana i nā ʻoihana ʻoihana. Ua hāpai ʻia nā hanana i ka hopohopo e pili ana i ka ʻoihana ma ke kula nui i kākoʻo kālā ʻia e ka lehulehu, a ua hōʻeuʻeu kekahi mau lālā o ke kumu a me nā mea ʻē aʻe e hoʻomaka i kahi hoʻopiʻi kū kānāwai e hoʻāʻo e loaʻa ka palapala "kuleana ʻike i ka simposium".

Hāʻawi kēia pepa ʻoiaʻiʻo i ka hope o kēia mau hanana, a me nā palapala mai ka hoʻopiʻi kū kānāwai a me ka hoʻokolokolo ʻana i nā moʻolelo lehulehu. Ua ʻōlelo ʻo U o S ua loiloi ia i kā Phillips hana ma ka pōʻaiapili o nā kulekele noiʻi noiʻi o ke kulanui. ʻO ka hopena, ua "hoʻokuʻu ʻia ʻo Phillips i kekahi hana hewa," e like me ka CBC News.

ʻO ka nūpepa News

ʻAʻohe o transparency i ka hana pū ʻana a Monsanto  

Noi nā palapala i loaʻa ma o nā moʻohelu lehulehu i nā leka uila e hōʻike ana i kekahi mau hana a Phillips me Monsanto. ʻO ka aʻe ka hōʻike o nā ʻike a me nā hana e pili ana i nā palapala.

I ka 2014, ua ʻimi ʻo Monsanto ke poʻokela o nā hana ʻepekema honua ʻo Eric Sachs iā Phillips a me ʻeono mau polofesa ʻē aʻe e kākau i nā haʻiʻōlelo e pili ana i nā GMO. Hōʻike nā leka uila i nā limahana o Monsanto manaʻo inoa a me nā kaha kiʻi no nā pepa, hoʻoponopono ʻia kā Phillips hana, hana i kahi paʻa PR, a hoʻonohonoho i hoʻopuka ʻia nā pepa a paipai ʻia ma o ka Hoʻopuka Haʻawina Genetic pūnaewele, nāna i hana haʻi ʻole o ko Monsanto kuleana. ʻO Phillips haʻi aku i ka CBC ʻaʻole ʻo ia i lawe i uku mai Monsanto a kū ma hope o nā kākau ʻana me kona inoa ma luna.

I ka 2015, ʻo Phillips ua kono ʻia nā limahana Monsanto, nā mea kōkua ʻoihana nui PR, koho i nā limahana kumu a me nā limahana o ke kulanui i kahi "Symposium on Research Management and the Right to Know" ma ka U o S e kūkākūkā ai i ke kūʻokoʻa o nā kānāwai ʻikepili a me nā hopena no nā ʻoihana ʻenehana-ʻoihana. Ua huki ʻia ka papa inoa kono kuka pu ana me ʻO Cami Ryan o Monsanto. Ua pani ʻia ka hanana i ka lehulehu a hōʻole ke kulanui e hoʻokuʻu i nā kikoʻī e pili ana iā ia.

I ka makahiki 2017, ua hoʻāʻo kahi hui e kapa iā lākou iho ʻo ka Academic Integrity Legal Group, me nā lālā o ke kumu a me nā poʻe ʻē aʻe i pili me U o S, e kiʻi i ka palapala akā ua ʻōlelo ʻia ua "kapa ʻia e ke kulanui." Nā hana kaumaha, me kahi 85% o ka palapala ʻeleʻele, "e hōʻike i kahi uhi uhi i manaʻo ʻia," ka ua kākau kahi hui i kahi palapala noi lehulehu i hōʻiliʻili ma mua o 1,800 mau inoa.

ʻO ka ʻāpana o ka transcript redact mai ka "Symposium on Research Management and the Right to Know"

ʻO Ron Kruzeniski, ka luna ʻikepili a me ka pilikino o Saskatchewan ka hihia o ka transcript redact. Ma Iune 2018 hōʻike, ʻōlelo ʻo Kruzeniski ʻaʻole i kūpono ke noi ʻana o ke kula nui i ke kānāwai moʻaukala lehulehu a ua paipai ʻo ia e hoʻokuʻu i kahi ʻāpana nui aʻe o ka transcript. Ua hōʻole ke kulanui e hāʻawi iā ia, e hoʻonāukiuki ana i kahi hoʻopiʻi kū kānāwai mai iā DʻArcy Hande, kahi archive archive ma U o S, ma ka inoa o ka hui Academic Integrity. ʻO ka hoʻāʻo kū kānāwai, ka mea a US Right to Know i kōkua ai e hoʻopukapuka, ʻaʻole i kūleʻa, me ka ʻaha a ka ʻaha i ʻōlelo ai "aia kekahi kānāwai no ka simposium i hoʻokumu i kahi ʻano pilikino."

Ua ʻōlelo ʻo Hande i kahi hālāwai ninaninau ua ʻike ʻia ka simposium ma ke ʻano he kūkākūkā pono e pili ana i ka kaohi ʻana i ka moʻolelo, ma mua o ka pane ʻana i nā hopohopo, e pili ana i ka hana pesticide ʻoihana me ke kula nui. Ma muli o ke kālā kālā ākea a U o S, manaʻo ʻo ia he kuleana ko ka lehulehu e ʻike i nā mea i kūkākūkā ʻia.

“Ua like ia me ka hui kalikāne makua.”

ʻO ka ʻōlelo hoʻoholo a ka ʻaha e pili ana, i ʻōlelo ʻo Hande, ma muli o ke koʻikoʻi i ka hoʻohana ʻia o ka Chatham House Rule (an ʻaelike kūpale hoʻohana ʻia e kōkua i nā kūkākūkā manuahi o nā kumuhana koʻikoʻi) ma ke ʻano he kumu e noho pilikino ka ʻikepili. "ʻO ka manaʻo o ka luna kānāwai he kūpono no ke kulanui lehulehu e hui pū me nā ʻelele ʻoihana e pili ana i ka dime lehulehu e kamaʻilio manuahi me ka ʻole o ka transparency koi ma lalo o ka Chatham House Rule, he mea hoʻopūʻiwa maoli ia," i ʻōlelo ʻo Hande. "Me he kalapu keiki kāne kahiko ia." 

palapala 

Hoʻololi i ka palapala o ka U of S “Symposium on Research Management and the Right to Know” 

Hōʻike Manaʻo 298-2017 Keʻena o ka ʻikepili a me ke kuleana pilikino Komisina Saskatchewan

Palapala noi a ka lehulehu mai ka Academic Integrity Legal Group

Aha o ka Aha Kuini Hoʻoholo, Hande vs U o S

Nā leka uila e pili ana i ka ʻelemu

Ke kono nei i nā hoa PR ʻoihana i U o S (ʻOkakopa 2015). Ua wehewehe ʻo Phillips i kona manaʻo e hoʻonohonoho i ka haʻiʻōlelo a puni ka kipa o ʻO Jon Entine (Papahana Heluhelu Genetic) a Kulanui o Florida Polokalamu Kevin Folta (ʻelua mau mea pale nui o GMO a me nā pesticides i hana pū me nā hui ʻoihana ʻoiai e koi ana he kūʻokoʻa lākou). Ua kākau ʻo Phillips iā Entine a me Folta: "I koʻu lohe ʻana ʻelua ʻolua i ke kaona, he manawa kūpono loa ia e hoʻākoakoa i kahi simposium noiʻi e kūkākūkā i ka neʻe ʻana o ka RTK [kuleana e ʻike] a me kona hopena e pili ana i nā hana ʻoihana-ʻoihana. ”

Papa kāʻei, papa kuhikuhi, poʻe i hele mai (Nowemapa 2015). Ua leka uila ʻo Phillips iā Entine, Folta, ʻelua mau limahana ʻo Monsanto a me nā mea ʻē aʻe e wehewehe ana i ka pono e ʻākoakoa e kūkākūkā i ka hoʻonui ʻia o ka loiloi o ka hana ʻoihana-ʻenehana. ʻO nā inoa o ka hapa nui o ka poʻe ʻole o ka poʻe S a ka poʻe i kono a ʻeleʻele hoʻi.

Hōʻike ʻo Monsanto i nā mea kono (Nowemapa 2015). Ua hāʻawi ʻo Monsanto Cami Ryan i nā manaʻo no ka papa inoa kono.

Nā leka uila e pili ana i nā pepa ʻo Monsanto / Genetic Literacy Project 

Ua hāʻawi ʻo Monsanto i mau pepa (ʻAukake 2013). Ua kākau ʻo Monsanto ʻo Eric Sachs i kahi hui o nā polopeka me Phillips, "Ua hoʻomaka wau i kahi papahana nui e hana i kahi papa ʻōlelo pōkole pōkole e pili ana i nā kumuhana koʻikoʻi i ke kahua biotechnology mahiʻai ... ua koho ʻia nā kumuhana ma muli o ko lākou mana i nā kulekele lehulehu, nā hua GM. ke kānāwai a me ka ʻae ʻana o ka poʻe kūʻai. ” Ua noi ʻo ia iā Phillips e kākau e pili ana i ka "ʻoi aku o ke kauā kaumaha" o nā GMO "e kāohi ana i ka hana hou ... he mea nui e kōkua ai i ke kākoʻo ʻana i ka palekana meaʻai ma ka honua holoʻokoʻa.

ʻO ka noi koi a Monsanto e neʻe i mua (Kepakemapa 9, 2014). Ua leka uila ʻo Sachs iā Phillips e koi iā ia e loiloi i nā hoʻoponopono i noi ʻia i kāna pepa. ʻO ka "ʻoihana ke ala ikaika i kēia manawa," i kākau ʻo Sachs. Ua wehewehe ʻo ia i ke kumumanaʻo "e hoʻohui i nā" kuanaʻike "o ka mea kākau mai kēia pūʻulu ʻōlelo pōkole i ka hoʻopaʻapaʻa e pili ana i nā hua GM a me nā meaʻai a mākou e manaʻo nei e hoʻomaka ʻia i nā pule aʻe e ka hōʻike hou a ka NRC Panel e pili ana i nā huaʻai GM. ʻO ka pule aʻe ka mea mua o nā hālāwai hoʻolohe manaʻo lehulehu ʻelua ma ka US NAS [National Academy of Science] ma Wakinekona a me kahi mea ʻike ʻo wai o nā loiloi huaʻai GM e hōʻike nei. ” Ua hoʻomaopopo ʻo Sachs ʻo Genetic Literacy Project "ʻo ia ka puka mua" no nā pepa a ke "kūkulu nei i kahi hoʻolālā kūʻai aku" me ke kōkua o kahi ʻoihana paʻa PR.

Ua ʻōlelo ʻo Monsanto i nā hoʻoponopono (Kepakemapa 18, 2014). Ua kūkākūkā ʻo Phillips i kāna holomua e hoʻokomo i nā hoʻoponopono a me nā hoʻololi mai Monsanto's Cami Ryan i loko o kāna ʻōlelo pōkole.

Hoʻonohonoho ʻo PR paʻa i nā papa kuhikuhi (ʻAukake 2013). ʻO Beth Ann Mumford o CMA Consulting, kahi paʻa PR e hana pū ana me Monsanto, i kūkākūkā i nā papa kuhikuhi a me nā palena manawa me nā polopeka. (CMA, a ua kapa inoa hou ʻia E nānā Hikina, ʻona e Charlie Arnot, Luna Nui o ka ʻoihana meaʻai-kālā wili pūʻulu Center no ka Pono Pono.)

ʻAʻole hōʻike i kā Monsanto kuleana (Kekemapa 11, 2014). ʻO ka pepa Phillips, i kapa ʻia ʻo “Nā hopena waiwai o nā hoʻoponopono o GM Crops” i paʻi ʻia e ka Genetic Literacy Project me ka hōʻike ʻole o kā Monsanto kuleana.

Kālā kālā

ʻOiai ua ʻōlelo ʻo Phillips ʻaʻohe ona kālā pololei mai nā ʻoihana, ʻike ʻia kāna noiʻi ʻana e loaʻa i kahi kākoʻo ʻoihana. ʻO ka Global Institute for Food Security (GIFS), a ua hoʻokumu ʻia kahi kula noiʻi e ke Aupuni o ʻO Saskatchewan, ke Kulanui o Saskatchewan a me Nutrien, kahi hui mea hoʻomomona, papa inoa iā Phillips i waena o kāna nā kānaka noiʻi pili. Wahi a Phillips ʻaoʻao kumu, kāna kālā noiʻi noiʻi hou loa e pili ana i nā pilina me Stuart Smyth, he polofesa pili ma U o S ka mea e paʻa ana i ka noho ʻimi noiʻi i loaʻa kālā i Agri-Food Innovation. ʻO kēlā kūlana kālā i kākoʻo kālā ʻia e ʻO Bayer CropSensya Kanada, ʻo CropLife Kanada, ʻo Monsanto Kanada, ke Komikina Hoʻolālā Canola ʻo Saskatchewan a me Syngenta Kanada.

Hoʻomaopopo ʻo kā Phillips kālā kālā ʻelua mau pilikino me Smyth: $ 675,000 no kahi “KOAUII-CSIPI Strategic Partnership "a" hōʻano hou i ke kālā no ka Project Maintenance no nā ʻepekema pilikanaka ma ke ʻano he ʻāpana o ka Cropsing Crops for Global Food Security, $ 37.5 miliona "mai ka Kanada First Research Excellence Fund Program (me ka waihona kālā he $ 1.31 miliona). ʻO ka hope he a holo ʻia ka papahana i kākoʻo kālā ʻia e ka lehulehu nā GIFS, ka lehulehu-pilikino pilikino e pili ana iā U o S, ke aupuni kūloko a me ka hui mea hoʻomomona Nutrien (ʻo Potash Corp ma mua), ka mea hoʻolaha i kāna huahana e like me ka mea e pono ai ka palekana o ka meaʻai.

Nāʻike e pili ana  

Quotes  

"ʻAʻole pono kā mākou kulanui e hana ma ke ʻano he wahi shilling no nā pono ʻoihana a me kahi antagonist ʻaneʻane hoʻowahāwahā ʻia o ke Komisina ʻIke a me ka pilikino pilikino ... nona nā manaʻo i hakakā me ka haʻaheo i ka ʻaha."

Len Findlay, Kumu Hoʻohanohano Emeritus, U o S (LTE, Ka pūʻā)

ʻO ka ʻaha a ka ʻaha hoʻokolokolo e “hoʻoikaika ai i ka palekana o ke kūʻokoʻa kula a me ka pilikino. Hāʻawi ke kūʻokoʻa kula i nā lālā o kā mākou kulanui e alualu i ka noiʻi a me nā manaʻo - ʻo ia hoʻi nā mea hoʻopaʻapaʻa a makemake ʻole ʻia - me ka makaʻu ʻole o ke komo. "

ʻO Karen Chad, ka U o S hope pelekikena o ka noiʻi (Ka pūʻā)

"Manaʻo wau e hauʻoli ka hapa nui o nā loea e pili ana i ka pilina pili loa me [Phillips '] me Monsanto."

ʻO Saskatoon consultant Steven Lewis, mea kākau huaʻōlelo o kahi mea i kaha ʻia
Ka ʻatikala a ka ʻAhahui Lapaʻau ʻo Kanada e pili ana i
pili pili i ke kula nui-ʻoihana (CBC)

“Ua makaʻu wau no ka mea [ʻoi aku ka maikaʻi o ka ʻoihana ʻoihana ma nā kula nui. Aia kekahi pilikia maoli. ”

U o kā S polofesa aʻo ʻo Howard Woodhouse,
mea nāna Ke kūʻai aku nei: ʻO ke kūʻokoʻa kula a me ka mākeke ʻoihana (CBC)

"Paipai mākou i kā mākou kumu e unuhi i kā lākou ʻike i loko o nā kulekele. ʻO ia nō kā Prof. Phillips i hana ai. ”

ʻO Jeremy Rayner, ka luna mua, ʻO Johnson Shoyama Hopu Kula Nui o ke Kulekele Aupuni (CBC)